Legal Spring Logo

"Why Shop or Review Legal Services anywhere else?"
Reviewing Legal Services Online
 LEGAL SPRING
     


Google
 
hypothetical case of X "discriminating against" X: possible?



"z"
2/8/2004 11:44:47 PM


Hypothetically, I am wondering if a person
of ethnicity/race X can be legally culpable
of discriminating against another person or persons
of his/her own ethnicity/race (ie, the person or
persons discriminated against are also of ethnicity/race X).
The prevailing opinion of at least some offices of diversity
that I have been exposed to seems to be that the answer
is no... or at least, skeptical to the point of being
what effectively amounts to the same thing as no.
Thanks for any tips/pointers/case citations.
 
 
"John D. Goulden"
2/8/2004 7:01:47 PM


Hypothetically, I am wondering if a person
of ethnicity/race X can be legally culpable
of discriminating against another person or persons
of his/her own ethnicity/race (ie, the person or
persons discriminated against are also of ethnicity/race X).
The prevailing opinion of at least some offices of diversity
that I have been exposed to seems to be that the answer
is no... or at least, skeptical to the point of being
what effectively amounts to the same thing as no.
Thanks for any tips/pointers/case citations.
Of course it is possible. A trivial example: a landlord, who happens to be a
member of a protected class, refuses to rent a dwelling to another member of
that same protected class and cites membership of that class as the reason
for refusal.
IANAL.
 
 
"Richard"
2/8/2004 7:49:21 PM


z wrote:
Hypothetically, I am wondering if a person
of ethnicity/race X can be legally culpable
of discriminating against another person or persons
of his/her own ethnicity/race (ie, the person or
persons discriminated against are also of ethnicity/race X).
The prevailing opinion of at least some offices of diversity
that I have been exposed to seems to be that the answer
is no... or at least, skeptical to the point of being
what effectively amounts to the same thing as no.
Thanks for any tips/pointers/case citations.
Yes. Not only is it possible, but you can probably find a few dozen cases
online about it.
You want a perfect example?
Look at the NBA and the college basketball teams.
90% of all players are black.
While those that run and manage the teams are white.
10 white guys who apply for the position, are overlooked simply because 1
black guy wants the job.
As compared to 30 or 40 years ago when it was the other way around.
 
 
Report this post for offensive content


site map |  disclaimer |  privacy
All Rights Reserved, Legal Spring, Inc. 2004