Legal Spring Logo

"Why Shop or Review Legal Services anywhere else?"
Reviewing Legal Services Online
 LEGAL SPRING
     


Google
 
Do I have a case??



"Unhappy"
2/14/2004 4:42:02 PM


Last week I was fired for getting into an accident with one of the company
vehicles..I dont have a problem with that, but here is what I do have a
problem with..
After the accident they continued to allow me to drive for two days, mon and
tue. Unknown to me they had placed an ad in the Sunday paper for my
position..On Tuesday my manager talked with human resource and they acted
like they were attempting to save my job.. I drove on that Tuesday.. On
Wednesday they fired me, the excuse was that I had placed a dent in a
trailer a few months earlier as well as the accident and they said I was too
much of a liability. Let me remind you that Sunday the ad was placed and on
monday and tuesday I was allowed to drive, they knew on Sunday they were
going to fire me..
Do I have a case against them???
 
 
"Richard"
2/14/2004 9:47:57 PM


Unhappy wrote:
Last week I was fired for getting into an accident with one of the
company vehicles..I dont have a problem with that, but here is what I do
have a problem with..
After the accident they continued to allow me to drive for two days, mon
and tue. Unknown to me they had placed an ad in the Sunday paper for my
position..On Tuesday my manager talked with human resource and they acted
like they were attempting to save my job.. I drove on that Tuesday.. On
Wednesday they fired me, the excuse was that I had placed a dent in a
trailer a few months earlier as well as the accident and they said I was
too much of a liability. Let me remind you that Sunday the ad was placed
and on monday and tuesday I was allowed to drive, they knew on Sunday
they were going to fire me..
Do I have a case against them???
Hire an attorney.
 
 
"McGyver"
2/15/2004 7:40:08 AM




"Unhappy" <Ihatemyboss@gunther.com> wrote in message
news:102t926jgp6i09e@corp.supernews.com...

Last week I was fired for getting into an accident with one of
the company
vehicles..I dont have a problem with that, but here is what I do
have a
problem with..
After the accident they continued to allow me to drive for two
days, mon and
tue. Unknown to me they had placed an ad in the Sunday paper
for my
position..On Tuesday my manager talked with human resource and
they acted
like they were attempting to save my job.. I drove on that
Tuesday.. On
Wednesday they fired me, the excuse was that I had placed a dent
in a
trailer a few months earlier as well as the accident and they
said I was too
much of a liability. Let me remind you that Sunday the ad was
placed and on
monday and tuesday I was allowed to drive, they knew on Sunday
they were
going to fire me..
Do I have a case against them???
You seem to be focussing on the idea that the company's stated
cause for firing you was hypocritical, since you are a good enough
driver that they kept you driving Monday and Tuesday after making
the decision to fire you, and then claimed that unsafe driving was
the cause. But that focus would be valid only if the company
needed good cause to fire you. If the employment relationship was
at-will, meaning the employer had the right to fire you without
cause, then it doesn't matter whether they told the truth about
the reason. If the company needed good cause to fire you,
because of a union contract or employment contract or whatever,
tell us about it.
McGyver
 
 
cj.green@worldnet.att.net (Christopher Green)
2/16/2004 1:40:41 AM


"Unhappy" <Ihatemyboss@gunther.com> wrote in message news:<102t926jgp6i09e@corp.supernews.com>...
Last week I was fired for getting into an accident with one of the company
vehicles..I dont have a problem with that, but here is what I do have a
problem with..
After the accident they continued to allow me to drive for two days, mon and
tue. Unknown to me they had placed an ad in the Sunday paper for my
position..On Tuesday my manager talked with human resource and they acted
like they were attempting to save my job.. I drove on that Tuesday.. On
Wednesday they fired me, the excuse was that I had placed a dent in a
trailer a few months earlier as well as the accident and they said I was too
much of a liability. Let me remind you that Sunday the ad was placed and on
monday and tuesday I was allowed to drive, they knew on Sunday they were
going to fire me..
Do I have a case against them???
You might have a case if you were denied unemployment, since it sounds
like you were not terminated for misconduct or any of the usual
reasons for denying unemployment benefits. If you apply for
unemployment and are denied, you can appeal through the unemployment
appeals procedure your state provides.
But employment in every state is at will, which means you can be
terminated for no reason or even what you believe is a bad reason or
in a bad manner -- unless you have a union or some contract of
employment that specifies otherwise.
To my thinking, it's not good personnel practice to leave somebody on
the job when you've already made a decision to terminate them -- but
that doesn't make it illegal or actionably unfair.
--
Not a lawyer,
Chris Green
 
 
Report this post for offensive content


site map |  disclaimer |  privacy
All Rights Reserved, Legal Spring, Inc. 2004